Entitled Parents, Reluctant Daughter

The answer I got implied that my folks had provided some financial assistance to my sibling at some point and that because of that, they were entitled to special grandparent treatment.

My parents basically said that I don’t have a right to tell them what to do or not to do. I respect that, despite the fact that I didn’t like that answer at all – then or now.

Now they are retired and miserable and broke. My mom has more than hinted on several occasions that she plans to move in with me if my dad passes away before her. They never planned for retirement financially.

Why does she feel entitled?

Should I feel obligated to help? Why would this responsibility fall solely on me? I feel like telling her that they cannot tell me what I can or cannot do in much the same way they told me.

Please share your opinion with me. I have no idea how to tackle the subject with them or my siblings, even though the topic keeps coming up again and again.

– Stung Daughter

Dear Stung:

Reading your narrative, I see “implying,” “hinting,” and actions speaking louder than words.

You seem to be the only person to have actually asked a family member a direct question: “Why do you favor my sibling’s children?” The answer you got: “You can’t tell me what to do,” isn’t an answer. It’s actually an unrelated statement.

I congratulate you for having full use of your voice, and I suggest that you continue to use it in a clear and authentic way – to state your intentions and exactly how you feel.

Your mother seems to have appointed you the family scapegoat. Your mother is entitled. She is entitled to her opinion, and not much beyond that.

If you don’t want your mother to live with you, then tell her so: “Mom, you’re going to have to look for other housing, because I am not willing to have you move in with me.” You could be helpful by researching low-income elder housing in your area.

Relationships in your family seem to be transactional. If that is the case, then you definitely don’t owe your parents anything, because – according to you – you haven’t received the thing you wanted the most from them – their attention.

Fortunately, you have siblings. They seem to have better relationships with your folks, and so you can toss the problem of the seemingly entitled parents in their direction.

In the tradition of the great personal advice columnists, Chicago Tribune’s Amy Dickinson is a plainspoken straight shooter who relates to readers of all ages. She answers personal questions by addressing issues from both her head and her heart. A solid reporter, Dickinson researches her topics to provide readers with informed opinions and answers – ranging from entitled parents, to family traditions, and an Alzheimer’s diagnosis secret.